|
British Studies Web Pages
HOME |
MAIL | EVENTS | INFO |
LINKS |
QUESTIONS |
MATERIALS
|
![]() |
| Book Review | |||||
|
Joanne Collie and Alex Martin, What’s It Like: Life and Culture in Britain Today,2000, Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, Britain. ISBN 0 521 58662 3 Student’s Book, ISBN 0 521 58661 5 Teacher’s Book, ISBN 0 521 58660 7 Cassette This review has been written by Adam Dalton, who taught British Studies at The British Council, Warsaw. At last we have a book that makes a
convincing attempt at combining EFL methodology with material on Britain and
British culture! Teachers have been waiting for just such a book since the last
Millennium. Was it worth the wait? In a word: maybe. The Student’s Book is organised into ten
thematised units, starting with some fairly refreshing units, like What Is Britain? and Cultural Diversity, but ending with more
predictable themes, like Education and
Leisure. Perhaps the early units are
a brave attempt at developing a critical context through which the student can
read the later units, but quite frankly the later units only deal with the
preoccupations of the white middle classes of Britain. And that’s the problem:
the book ducks tough issues like class in Britain all too often. There are no
units on politics, history, empire, religion or the Royal Family. Having said that, the units may have
been chosen much more carefully than has so far been suggested. After all, do
we really need another book that deals with the hackneyed old themes that we
all know inside out? Why should the book waste one of its units on dealing with
British history, when there are plenty of useful books and materials out there already
(albeit that we have to adapt the format of the materials)? This book might be
trying to do something else altogether. The book does not look backwards at the
old institutions of Britain, but tries to look forward (at the dawning of the
new Millennium) and give a cross-section of life in modern Britain. And another point to make is that
the book has clearly been written with younger students in mind. The book
avoids boring and heavy topics in order to try and appeal to a particular
audience. That audience is the international market, a market that is getting
younger and younger. The book wants to give a flavour of Britain but at the
same time stay general enough for foreign students to be able to relate to
their own personal experience when dealing with the topics (as an example, the
last unit is entitled Being Young Today).
On such counts, the book is very successful. That flavour of Britain comes via
the bright and useful pictures, the
authentic texts (including, newspapers, extracts from plays and novels,
magazines, and leaflets), the snappy but meaty activities and the interesting,
varied listenings (with an variety of authentic accents!). The book is
appealing to the eye, user-friendly, easily accessible and dynamic – everything
Blair’s Britain might wish to be, some might say. It is pitched at an
upper-intermediate level of English and should appeal to those of a secondary
school age (though that does not mean to say the book has nothing to offer
older students). The activities never focus on particular
language points – this is not an English language teaching book, anyway – and
generally represent an integrated skills approach to teaching; an approach that
has thus far not been explored to the full in mainstream British Studies
teaching. The result is a well-presented book
with possibly something to contribute to the teaching of British Studies, but a
book that may lack substance for those with a deeper interest in British
culture. The image of Britain that
comes across in this book is that of a Britain where life is happy and
harmonious and there is no controversy. There is no intolerance or anxiety,
only community festivals and cultural integration. Sadly, this is not the
Britain I know. |
| Produced in Poland by British Council © 2003. The United Kingdom's international organisation for educational opportunities and cultural relations. We are registered in England as a charity. |