/LOGO>
| Teachers' Forum HOME | MAIL | EVENTS | INFO | LINKS | QUESTIONS | MATERIALS |
|
Postgraduate Diploma Producing a Guidebook - a project for a trip to Britain | |||||
|
This article is based on the diploma work of Joanna Głowiak from Gliwice submitted in 2001 for the Studium Podyplomowe Kształcenia i Doskonalenia Nauczycieli Języka Angielskiego. For more about the Studium Podyplomowe - see Postgraduate diploma projects and the approach to culture in language teaching taken there - see The Methodology of British Studies on the Postgraduate Diploma Programme
OutlineThis diploma work showed how the gimnazjum students were able to be fully involved in a trip to Britain by being given responsibility for producing parts of a guidebook to be used by students on the following year’s trip. The guide not only included where to go but also what to take, what to do if you get ill, transport in the UK etc - some sample materials are given as links. This enabled the students not only to be involved during the trip but also before and especially after. It also enabled the trip to have an actual classroom and display product to demonstrate the work done to the rest of the school. Such an idea can be followed up in future years by students checking the guide already written and adding their own material. The work also includes a day-by-day account of the trip which brings to life the circumstance under which the guide was written.
As many of the links connect to original student work you will find some slips of language there
Preparation activity before the trip After the trip - planning the guidebook (including links to the guidebook pages) Appendix - teacher guidelines for trips Links to selected items of the finished guidebook
IntroductionThe main aim is to present the set of tasks designed by the author to enable the production of a guidebook for use on school trips to the UK. This project included not only the participants but also those who were unable to go and shows how such students can be involved even so. This work presents the author's assessment of the practicality of such an approach. The guide was written by first year gimnazjum students to help those in following years make the most of their trip, and to motivate all of them to add to their learning of English by using their own, and their fellow students', real experiences.
Trips to an English-speaking countryTravel agencies have recently been developing in many ways and one example is the organising of school trips to a foreign country. There are lots of advantages to such trips, if they are well organised and properly prepared. One of most important is that they are highly motivating when students discover that it is not only possible but also pleasant to use English in the real world. What is more, learners can see, feel, taste and touch the culture which they had learned about. Places mean more than they meant before the trip and students can find proof of what their teachers had told them about during English lessons. Finally, magnificent experiences and the unforgettable memories which are brought home will give students a great amount of pleasure for a long time. It is not rare that they start planning another trip just after coming back from the previous one. However, there are disadvantages, too. A real problem is the cost. There should be at least forty participants on a trip to reduce the price therefore it may be necessary to organise a group by inviting students from other classes or even other schools. This causes additional work for the teacher who is responsible for the trip.
Guidebook project objectivesTwo parallel aims are present behind the idea of preparing a guidebook. One was directed at the participants of the trip to England to motivate and produce a longer-term activity. This starts by putting learner’s expectations connected with the places to be visited into words before the trip, through enjoying every moment of the stay in England, to recalling the most memorable events and places after. The second aim was to awake in the other students cultural awareness and a desire to go on a trip next time, dispel any anxiety of the unknown and help them be prepared to take all the advantages and pleasure which such a trip can give them.
Participant descriptionThe guidebook project involved a group of sixteen 14-year-old girls who are first-year gimnazjum students. All of them had been abroad before but none in an English speaking country. This group was chosen as ten of them were to be participants on our trip to England. Most of the girls are rather good students at an intermediate level of English, but there are also a few weaker ones. They have been learning English for six years now and since the beginning of this school year they have had three English lessons a week. Probably many of them attend some extra courses or take private lessons as well. This semester we have started the third book of “0pen Doors" by Norman Whitney. Some of the recent topics which could be associated with the project were: the story of London, describing places and people, and expressing opinions and preferences. Some months ago they watched a video documentary about London produced by Longman. The teacher noticed that those who were participants on the trip found a lot of enjoyment in doing the project, whereas the rest of the group did it as regular class work.
Preparation activity before the tripAimThe first task had been given to the students a few days before they left for England. Its aim was to put the students in a mood of anticipation, to elicit their wishes and identify their present knowledge of England to be compared with their impressions after having been there. The teacher was also curious what ideas her students had connected with Britain.
ProcedureAll the project group, not only the participants of the excursion, were asked to write their answers to the question: “What would be the most interesting experience or thing to see while visiting England?" No prior information was given in order to use the students' own knowledge as the source, and therefore, get their first thoughts on the topic. In order not to copy somebody else's ideas the teacher stopped students each time they wanted to ask the others. As a second task the students who were going to England were asked to keep diaries or notes during the seven days of the journey.
ObservationThe first striking thing which was noticed was the fact that for all of the children England meant London, and London meant famous places. Madame Tussaud's Gallery, Tower Bridge and Oxford Street took the three top positions. Unfortunately, most names were misspelled as the students knew them only by hearing.
EvaluationThe way the writing was done seemed to be reliable as the information was written individually. It could be a bit stressful especially for weaker students and mistakes in their writing could have been avoided by giving students more time or assigning it as homework. However the outcome would not be authentic because of the possibility of using different sources and not their own knowledge, as the learner-based method demands. The preparation phase was of great importance for producing the guidebook. The students knew the reason for making notes and were able to visualise the whole structure of the project. They could compare the pieces written in this stage with their actual experiences on the trip and after it. This way they were finally able to decide what should be included in the guidebook and what was of real value for use by the next generation of participants.
The trip to England The trip will be described to give a sense of reality and context for which the students developed the ideas for the guidebook. The school trip in question took place from April 30 to May 4, 2001 and was organised by the ATAS agency in Katowice. Forty-two young people, among them 35 from our gimnazjum, and three teachers travelled by coach via Germany, the Netherlands, Belgium to Calais in France from where under the English Channel to London. For an outline of the trip - see Programme (Polish only)
Day oneArriving in London a bit earlier than scheduled, the teachers and the guide decided that the group would walk through Greenwich. There the students could put one foot in the eastern hemisphere and the other in the western. We could look across London with its Millenium Dome from the top of the hill and went down to see the Cutty Sark. Then we went under the Thames by an old foot tunnel to take a ride by a modem railway through the Docklands. After admiring the St. Katharine's Dock area we spent four hours visiting the Tower. Here, for the first time, the students had to find the way themselves by reading signposts and asking people. They could choose the most interesting things from what had been introduced to them by the guide. Everybody was much too tired to pay any attention to our awful accommodation in a Polish school somewhere in the outskirts of south London. We did not even examine our dinner despite the fact that it was the time of panic because of BSE and foot-and-mouth disease.
Day twoThe second day of visiting London we started at Madame Tussaud's which was breathtaking. Here again they needed to use English, mainly while listening to the sound guide. Hundreds of photos were taken there! (some of them were used in the final guidebook). From the gallery we went via Baker Street to Oxford Street where in small groups everyone rushed to do shopping. There was only one disaster when a girl bought an expensive bottle of perfume for herself which turned out to be for men. The others were very proud of their ability to communicate (see the students' impressions in the guidebook - Shopping). The same day after walking down Regent Street, through Leicester Square, Piccadilly Circus and China Town we came to Trafalgar Square and the National Gallery. This last was not interesting for the students after such exciting experiences as shopping in London. Our coach took us to our place of accommodation. There was a Catholic church nearby and it was Sunday, so we went there, but it was late and the priest celebrated the holy mass specially for our group which was very nice of him. On our way home we came across a pub with a separate area for children. Drinking real English lemonade in a real English pub was a great surprise for all participants. To have a look at the inside of the pub our students visited the toilets very often! Day threeThe last day in London the group started by visiting Westminster. One girl was ill and she with one teacher had to see a doctor. On the other bank of the Thames there is St. Thomas Hospital and its emergency department helped the girl, which allayed the fears of both her and her parents (see the guidebook - Problems with health). The rest of the group visited Westminster Abbey, admired Westminster Bridge and the Houses of Parliament and listened to Big Ben striking. From Westminster the route led along St. James's Park with its plants and animals to Buckingham Palace. A further route, chosen on purpose, took us to Harrod's. Here again the students had some time to explore the most fantastic shop by themselves. To their astonishment they were not allowed to go in one entrance. The guard divided them into groups and showed entrances in other comers and streets. The best place they visited that day was the Natural History Museum where they could experience, do and touch almost everything that had been always impossible or even forbidden while visiting museums in Poland. It looked as if they would have liked to spend all week there. Students' impressions from visiting London can be found in the Guidebook (see the guidebook - London). The same evening the group arrived at Oxford Youth Hostel and at dinner some of the students found very eager companions for talking to in English (see the guidebook - Use your English - Don't worry, be happy).
Day fourThe next morning the students were given a choice for traditional English breakfast, continental or vegetarian one. This time only a few decided to have eggs and bacon, beans and sausages but it changed the following day. After breakfast our guide took us to the impressive mediaeval castle of Warwick in which the students could see and smell how the life looked like in former times. Everywhere they were enveloped with British culture, even sitting in the Victorian rose garden they thought about the Secret Garden they knew from literature. After a short visit in the charming town of Warwick the route led us to Stratford-upon-Avon full of remembrances of Shakespeare. In his birthplace a woman hearing that the group was from Poland drew some students into a longer conversation and explained to them some language mysteries e.g. origins of the word 'mattress' and the saying 'good night, sleep tight'. After some time for shopping we returned to Oxford to have a sightseeing tour of the city on the top deck of a bus. It was extremely cold and windy which disturbed the students very much while listening to the sound guide on the bus, and the ride was not very enjoyable for them. Again they had some time to buy souvenirs and we returned to the hostel for dinner and continued the previous day chatting.
Day fiveThe last day in England, in pouring rain, we visited the St. Magdalene and Christ Church colleges. Going back to Dover we visited Windsor Castle and later we admired the green landscapes of Kent. Packed with memories, impressions and souvenirs both all trip participants and the teachers spent the following night and day on the coach planning the next trip. This time to Scotland perhaps.
After the trip - planning the guidebookAims
Objectives
ProcedureThe activities in the lesson were fully learner-based. There was time for memories while showing and discussing the pictures which the teacher asked the trip participants to bring to the class. Some of the pictures and events needed more detailed commenting on to make the setting more clear or to share students’ impressions with those who had not been. Afterwards, students discussed the form of the guidebook. They decided that it would be an A4-sized booklet printed on a computer. Then, remembering all comments on the photos and looking at their pieces of writing from the preparation task done before the journey, the students decided the following sections:
As this is the original guidebook produced by the students you will find some slips of language there
The children organised themselves into five groups. At this point of the lesson some negotiations were necessary to put together the weaker students with the better ones and those who had visited England with the others who had not. It was suggested to the students that they chose topics closely connected with their own experiences (the girl who visited a doctor - the part about health, those who were cold all the time - the one on clothes, and so on). Additionally, each group described one town. One girl was chosen to design and make the cover page and was responsible for the editorial work. For the next lesson the girls were asked to bring some photos suitable for the chosen topics as well as folders, dictionaries and other sources and materials.
ObservationThe students took to the task enthusiastically as they thought it to be an easy piece of work done in groups and they expected that some would write while the others could pretend only. However, after grouping and choosing the topics they realised that everyone had to be involved entirely. While commenting on the photos and at the moment of grouping the students, Polish was spoken. Students were talking not only about the places they visited but also about their feelings and impressions, they were stating their opinions and finally they ranked the places according to their likes and dislikes. More aspects of the trip were discussed e.g. habits observed like wearing school uniforms, queuing at bus stops, walking on a particular side of the pavement or people they had the opportunity to talk to. Also money: what and where to buy, what is worth its price, expensive cars etc.
EvaluationDuring the lesson the children touched on more ideas than famous buildings only, they familiarised their classmates with a wider view of England through recalling memories and describing their observations. Lots of Polish was spoken, which was unavoidable because of the great emotions which accompanied those events. In this context the motivation of the students was more important than the language, but still the children learned a lot of vocabulary. What is more, when the girls decided on the topics, they were revising communication skills quite unconsciously.
Producing the guidebookAims
ProcedureThere were three stages to the work: 1. The lesson started with students taking their places in their previous groups and getting all materials ready. Then they wrote their own sub-topics on the sheets in front of them. The teacher reminded the learners of the writing objectives once more and they started working. One girl in group IV, who was responsible for conducting a survey on the best places visited in England, wrote all the names of the places on the blackboard. She asked the trip participants individually and they marked three places allocating one, two or three points. The girl prepared a report on the survey. The person responsible for designing the cover was making some draft copies. The teacher was monitoring the work and each paragraph was shown to the teacher before writing the next. 2. Having finished their writing one group after another read out their pieces to the class, discussed the layout of the pages in groups and in particular cases between groups. Then, by a class vote, the best cover was chosen. 3. Finally, the students arranged appointments to have their works printed and decided on a sensible deadline for collecting them to bind into a booklet.
ObservationThe teacher noticed that some of them had their books open on topics relevant to their piece of writing. There were a lot of mistakes. Most of them concerned word order, spelling, and prepositions as the students found it difficult to choose the right one, even using a dictionary. But this time, in contrast to the preparation stage, almost all proper names were written correctly. There was a lot of peer help and personal involvement during the group work. The weaker or more lazy were supported by their partners to get involved in writing and finally they co-operated successfully. Some difficulties occurred at the last stage of the work. Not all groups kept to the deadline for reasons of health and holidays. As the end of the school year was near the group and the teacher decided to put all the pieces together in September and wait till then for the end product. Some students, before printing their work, made some changes, probably influenced by listening to others. Several ideas were put forward by the students after the teacher's correction as the learners were not willing to follow her suggestions as far as the content was concerned. This is a consequence of learner-centred teaching.
EvaluationThanks to the work on the project the students had the opportunity to learn how to cooperate successfully as they had to hand in a complete piece of work to the teacher. The guidebook, the product of the project work, will be very useful for the next trip to help avoid the problems and misunderstandings described in it. The project group, as planned, once again were in contact with different aspects of English culture and life. They could learn the spelling of places situated on the route while their work with a dictionary enriched their vocabulary and improved their skill in finding appropriate words. At first the teacher was disappointed with the balance of English and Polish spoken because she was sure that the students knew enough language to have done all this better. Then she realised that it happened because there were emotions involved and it was too embarrassing to express the feelings in a foreign language. Students' personal input while producing the guidebook gave them a lot of satisfaction.
ConclusionsTaking students on a trip to England and following it up by writing a guidebook was a great opportunity for students to develop many cultural skills in one complete cycle. Working on the guidebook the students felt as if the trip was much longer than it was in fact. The culture which they encountered and experienced was also multiplied through involving in activities those students who were not on the trip. Apart from the cultural aims the writing enriched the students' language skills. Choosing project work as the way of discussing memories, impressions and intercultural aspects, in association with learner-based methods while working on the project was a good idea. This allowed children to use the trip and their experiences as a productive source of knowledge of the target country. The autonomy they developed made the guidebook authentic and gave the students a lot of pleasure and sense of achievement. The author is convinced that trips to target countries have to be associated with a series of tasks preparing, accompanying and following the trip itself to get the maximum of the opportunity of going abroad. All these enable learners to be prepared for finding differences and similarities, to avoid miscommunication and to develop tolerance and sympathy towards other societies. In such a way learners become interculturally competent and the trip participants showed this competence when they discussed the topics for the guidebook with the other students involved into the project. The teacher is planning to expand the guidebook after the next trip. Also an idea for writing a similar guidebook for an English group of students coming to Katowice has recently been introduced to another group of students.
Appendix - teacher guidelines for tripsHere are some pieces of advice for teachers who are going abroad with their groups based on the author's experience
Preparation
The trip itself
Follow-up
|
|
Produced in Poland by British Council © 2004. The United Kingdom's international organisation for educational opportunities and cultural relations. We are registered in England as a charity. |